Review : Kaminey


Note : The edited version of this review appears at Planet Bollywood, here.

Rating : Excellent (4.4/5)
Genre : Drama
Year : 2009
Running time : 2 hours 15 minutes
Director : Vishal Bharadwaj
Cast : Shahid Kapoor, Priyanka Chopra, Amole Gupte, Chandan Roy Sanyal, Tenzing Nima
Kid rating : PG-13


Need I spell out the obvious ? Need I tell you that it’s all true – the hype, the adoring reviews, the awe ? Because it is; Kaminey is all I’d hoped for and then some. Vishal Bharadwaj’s directorial venture after his last Omkaara, which released in 2006, Kaminey is the ultimate mix of arty and commercial cinema, giving us quality-hungry folk what we desire most – a classy, captivating film.

As I said in the preview this is the story of two unique heroes, twin brothers with speech impediments; Charlie lisps, and Guddu stammers. Good-natured, honest Guddu is in trouble with Sunil “Chopper” Bhope (Amol Gupte), a Maharashtrian political criminal, when Bhope finds out that Guddu has impregnated his (Bhope’s) sister Sweety (Priyanka). Small-time crook Charlie, having gotten his hands on some contraband, finds it being whisked away from under his nose, and digs in his heels. Both must fight their way out of this chaos, Guddu for the love of his life, and Charlie for his big-time dreams.

The story is a lark and Bhardwaj has fun with it. Along with subtle humor, we are also treated to moments of irony; Guddu, who for his NGO, advocates the usage of condoms, doesn’t wear one himself, and lands himself in a predicament. There are gun-toting, eccentric villains galore, from the trio of Bangla brothers for whom Charlie works, to the very Mumbaikar Bhope and the North-eastern Tashi . And the story uses their “local” nuances to define their characters; the Bengali brothers spout Bangla in passion, Mumbaikar Bhope has an aversion for the migrant U.P-ite, while Tashi must prevent a business deal with his African brothers-in-law from going sour.

One might not imagine that heroes with speech impediments would actually hold interest, but then one probably hasn’t figured Shahid Kapur into the mix. Shahid plays both Guddu and Charlie with aplomb; ruthless Charlie smilingly telling Bhope that he pronounces “Fa for Fa” (Fa for Sa), or Guddu stammering so hard on being questioned by the cops that one wondered if he would even finish the sentence. Shahid was always a good actor, but in this film, we finally glimpse the acting chops he has inherited from his father, Pankaj Kapoor.

Priyanka also outdoes herself as Sweety. Shrill in anger, squeaky with relief, or tremulous with emotion – she does it all well. Amol Gupte, the writer of the sensitive kiddie film “Taare Zameen par” makes a convincing villain, as ready-to-sell-my-own-mother Bhope. And Chandan Sanyal was impressive as Mikhail, Charlie’s friend and partner-in-crime. The rest of the supporting cast is also very effective and believable.

The film’s screenplay is delightful, and Bharadwaj, as expected wields the directorial reins firmly. Kaminey has some excellent music, also provided by Bharadwaj ; while the almost cult number “Dhan-te-nan” is dance-floor and action-groovy, the soft ballad like tones of “Mohabbat ki hain” are firmly entrenched in new-found love.

Kaminey (Bollywood Movie, Indian Cinema, Hindi Film / DVD)Kaminey is a good film – the kind of film that I would want more of, and more often. However if there was one thing that I would have qualms about, it would be the almost potboiler-ish ending, because it seemed so in-your-face and obvious for an otherwise subtle and nuanced film.

Kidwise : This gets a PG-13 rating for gun-fight sequences, and some strong violence.

Tags : Kaminey movie reviews, Kaminey film reviews, Kaminey review, Kaminey reviews, reviews of Kaminey

This entry was posted in 2009, All Netflix, bollywood, drama, Hindi movies on Netflix, outstanding, rating-PG13, recommended. Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to Review : Kaminey

  1. Raj says:

    You rated Love Aaj Kal as 4.3 and called it "Excellent" and yet you call Kaminey "Above average" at 4.4? Unfair! 😛

  2. magjay says:

    It's pretty good…I'm in.

  3. AMODINI says:

    Thanks for pointing that out – fixed now. Happy ? 🙂

  4. Great review unfortunately i would have to wait for it on dvd as no cinema near me is showing it

  5. sweets says:

    I 'm not interested in kaminey..

  6. AMODINI says:

    Oh – that's too bad, hopefully it'll be on DVD soon.

  7. I doubt Kaminey deserve such a rating. It was not at all a great film,

  8. Anonymous says:

    I doubt a dumb film like Kaminey has such a good rating.
    The entire film in dark, Editing is horrible, Not a great photography either and worst of all is climax.

  9. Anonymous says:

    i disagree with anonymous..i mean i can see that people can have a problem with the ending or climax though i don't even mind that i got so seduced by the film but it's definitely not dumb(n not for the dumb either-if u were expecting to sit back n not use ur brains throughout the movie then u'd obviously not get any of it)…if u don't like dark movies well then this was obviously not the movie for u but its a gross misrepresentation to say that the editing was bad-the movie keeps flippin from 1 plot to d other but that's how it becomes a thriller creating the suspense n even then they all hold together firmly…it was so well-done with the story so taut i couldn't take my eyes off it even once n so was the photography pretty good!-Debbie

  10. andy says:

    I found the movie hard to understand in parts. The shot in the hotel where two dead persons are shown and the police chap is waiting for drugs seems incomplete. I understand that the background story was chopped at editing table leaving it incoherent. The climax seemed to be shot with great pains but when seen in theatre seems to be jumpy and erratic. A good percentage of the audience did not follow the story fully. It seems as though the director wanted to show his brilliance and control over the medium without taking into account that most audience would like to have an easily understandable story.

    It is easy to write a long and complicated sentence. Small and simple sentences are much harder.

    This applies to films also.

  11. Anonymous says:

    I didn't find Kaminey that great a movie I understood it but it wasn't anything out of the ordinary. Pretty average film if you ask me.

  12. Taheera says:

    For a bollywood movie this movie was extremely good on cinematography,directory and well everything I think shahid kapoor and priyanka acted good!Most bollywood movies are just overwhelmed with lame comedys and just toooo romantically cheesy happenings!this movie has done well

  13. Pingback: Movie Review : Haider (2014) | Amodini's Movie Reviews

Comments are closed.